Audio Innovations

Car Stereos, Auto Customizing, Mobile Electronics

1105 Jim's Lane, Conway, AR 72032 501-358-6545
  • Home
  • Services
    • Car Audio
    • Driver Safety Systems
    • Marine Audio
    • Motorcycle Audio
    • Radar and Laser Detector Systems
    • Remote Starters
  • About Us
  • Location
  • Customer Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Explaining Audio Signal Phase and Polarity

Signal Phase

Understanding how DC voltages combine is quite simple. They add linearly when we wire sources (like batteries) in series. But understanding how AC waveforms combine is complicated. AC waveforms don’t always sum intuitively unless the peaks and valleys align perfectly. We see many examples where people interchange the terms phase and polarity. In reality, those words refer to different phenomena. Let’s take a close look at audio signal phase and polarity.

What Is an Audio Signal?

We will use sinusoidal waveforms as our example audio signals for this discussion. The sounds we hear are combinations of infinite frequencies. If you look at music on an oscilloscope, it would look something like the image below.

Signal Phase
A few milliseconds of an audio signal waveform as would be seen on an oscilloscope.

Phase refers to the relative timing between two waveforms. A single waveform can’t have phase. We must compare it to something else. As such, we will need a reference waveform for this article. You can see that below.

Signal Phase
Our reference waveform for this article.

In Phase

Let’s start with the basics. When we describe two waveforms as “in phase,” we infer that the peaks and valleys are aligned. The starting point of the waveform should happen at the same time. The image below shows two waveforms that are “in phase.”

Signal Phase
The pink and yellow audio waveforms shown here are in phase and perfectly align with each other.

Two waveforms can be in phase but have amplitude differences. The image below shows that condition.

Signal Phase
Two waveforms that are in phase but have different amplitudes.

Reverse Polarity

We often see amplifiers with a switch that inverts the polarity of the audio signal passing through the devices. These are frequently and mistakenly labeled as “Phase.” Let’s explain.

Phase is the relative difference in time between two signals. Polarity refers to a contrasting waveform direction. In DC voltage, we know that if we put a voltmeter’s red lead on the battery’s positive terminal and the black lead on the negative, we’ll see a positive voltage. If we reverse the leads and put the red on the negative and the black on the positive, we’ll see a negative voltage on a digital meter. We call this “having the polarity backward.”

In AC waveforms, the same thing happens. If two waveforms have the same starting point and frequency, but one goes positive while the other goes negative, we refer to one being in the opposite polarity.

Here are our two audio waveforms in the oscilloscope. The yellow waveform shows the opposite polarity to that of the pink waveform.

Signal Phase
The pink waveform has the reverse polarity of the yellow waveform.

Let’s consider this in terms of audio signals going to a speaker. The speaker driven by the yellow signal would start from rest and then initially move forward. The speaker driven by the pink signal would begin moving toward the magnet. Activating the polarity switch has the same effect as swapping the positive and negative speaker wire connections.

Signal Phase
An example of an amplifier with an incorrectly labeled polarity control switch.

The image above shows an amplifier with the polarity control switch incorrectly labeled as phase. As a bonus, the amplifier has the infrasonic filter incorrectly marked Subsonic. This labeling is a fairly common error.

If the above amplifier could adjust the phase of the waveform of one signal to be 180 degrees from the other, the waveforms would look like this:

Signal Phase
An example of two waveforms with a phase shift of 180 degrees.

Phase

When discussing phase shifts, we include the peaks and valleys of a waveform and the starting time. This start point or time is especially crucial to discussing audio signals that are never sinusoidal. The starting times move if there is a phase shift between two signals. A difference in starting times implies a delay on one of the waveforms. We can do this quickly and deliberately with a digital signal processor. Adding delay is common in “time aligning” the left and right speakers in a stereo sound system.

Electricians and engineers often discuss phase angles in AC waveforms when driving inductive loads like electric motors. In these cases, the voltage applied to the motor may be “out of phase” with the current flowing through the motor. The same thing happens with speakers and passive crossover networks. These components’ reactive elements (inductance and capacitance) can cause the current and voltage to be “out of phase.” These phase shifts are why we can’t accurately measure the power out of an amplifier without measuring the phase angle between current and voltage. If that was confusing, don’t fret. These are concepts that engineers and technicians learn about in college.

We often talk about degrees when discussing the phase of two waveforms. One complete cycle of a sine wave is 360 degrees. A half-cycle is 180 degrees. The angle between when the sine wave initially moves from the 0-volt level to the first peak is 90 degrees. Here is an example of a 90-degree phase shift between two waveforms:

Signal Phase
In this example, the yellow waveform lags the pink waveform by 90 degrees.

Here’s what a 360-degree phase shift looks like:

Signal Phase
In this example, the yellow waveform lags the pink waveform by 360 degrees.

Understanding that the starting points of the two waveforms differ is crucial to understanding how audio waveforms interact. If you were to “align” the peaks and valleys, we’d think these signals were “in phase.” This practice is a common issue for people who try to “time align” a subwoofer to a midbass speaker by reversing the polarity of one relative to the other, then adjusting a delay so there is a sizeable acoustic null shown on an RTA at the crossover frequency. This practice doesn’t consider the start time of the audio signals. Considering phase and start time is required to deliver a system where the sound from the subwoofer arrives at the listening position at the same time as the midbass or midrange drivers.

Why Are Signal Phase and Polarity Important in Car Audio Systems?

For people who’ve upgraded their vehicles with a radio and two pair of speakers, the primary concern is that the acoustic polarity of all the speakers in the system is the same. When a speaker produces a sound, it should combine acoustically with the output of other speakers in the system. You can test this quickly without any special tools.

Play music with a reasonable amount of bass. Use the balance and fader controls to listen to one speaker at a time. Start with the front left speaker. Now, use the balance to add the front right speaker so both play. The relative bass level should increase when you add the second speaker. If it doesn’t, the wiring likely has a polarity problem.

Repeat the test with the front left speaker playing, then use the fader control to add the left rear speaker. Once again, the bass should increase. If it does, fade rearward so only the left-rear speaker is playing. Now, use the balance control to add the right-rear speaker. Once again, we should get more bass. If the bass decreases when a second speaker plays, drop by a local specialty mobile enhancement retailer and ask them to check the wiring.

Signal Phase
Using the fader and balance controls on your radio is an easy way to ensure that all speakers work together.

Signal Summing and Cancellation

Sometimes the distances between speakers cause incomplete summing of all frequencies. Let’s go back to looking at audio waveforms for a second. If two signals have the same amplitude, frequency content and starting times, how they add together (called summing) is predictable.

Signal Phase
The blue trace is the sum of two signals that are in phase.

In the example above, the signals combine perfectly and the total amplitude doubles. An example would be listening to music at home on a set of stereo speakers and sitting equidistant from both speakers. When it’s perfect, or at least pretty good, signals that are equal in amplitude and in phase in both channels appear to come from a spot between the speakers. Some call this a “phantom center image.” It’s just how stereo recording works and doesn’t require a fancy name.

Let’s look at how signals with different phase relationships sum. First, let’s look at two waveforms, of which one is reversed in polarity.

Signal Phase
The blue trace shows the result of combining the pink and yellow traces.

If one speaker moves outward and the other moves inward, their output should cancel. If you have a pair of subwoofers and one is wired backward, the result is that the system produces no bass.

Now, what happens when one signal arrives before another? Here are the waveforms if one signal lagged the other by 90 degrees:

Signal Phase
The result of combining audio signals where there is a 90-degree delay between them.

A few bad things happen when signals don’t start simultaneously. In terms of the combined waveforms, the amplitude only increases by 25% instead of 100%. This happens if you’re at home, sitting much closer to one stereo speaker than the other. The same happens in your car, where the left door speaker is maybe 30 inches away, and the right is 45 inches away.

Audio Content and Signal Summing

Remember, music is not a single frequency, as we’ve shown in the oscilloscope plots. It’s a combination of thousands of frequencies. We don’t talk about the phase between audio signals; we talk about delay times. Every frequency has a different wavelength. So if there is a timing difference between the signals, some frequencies combine, and others cancel. The result produces an uneven frequency response.

Let’s combine some signals in Adobe Audition to demonstrate this.

I created two sine sweeps. These are 20-second tracks that start at 20 Hz and increase in frequency by 20 kHz. The image below shows that the left and right channels are equal in amplitude and phase.

Signal Phase
A portion of our sine sweeps showing that the left and right channels are equal in phase and amplitude.

Let’s look at the frequency response of the two signals:

Signal Phase
Averaged frequency response of the two sine sweeps.

The frequency response graph isn’t perfectly flat because I don’t have control over the speed at which the sweep occurs. In short, the bass is present for longer than the highs. What you need to know is that the response is flat and smooth.

Let’s add about 1.7 milliseconds of delay to the right channel waveform. This is the time it takes sound to travel about 24 inches. That’s not an uncommon path length difference between a vehicle’s left and right speakers.

Signal Phase
The results of combining two sine sweeps with one channel delayed 1.7 milliseconds from the other.

As you can see, the results are dramatic. The frequency response is full of dips. We call this comb filtering, which happens when two sound sources are at different distances from the listening or measuring position. This could be attributed to path length differences between speakers or to a speaker’s sound reflecting off a surface and recombining with the direct-path sound. If there are path length differences, your installer can use a digital signal processor to delay the signal to the closer speaker. There isn’t much you can do about reflections other than to relocate the speakers.

Audio Signal Phase and Polarity

We hope this serves as a primer to help you understand the concepts of audio signal phase and polarity. A solid understanding of these concepts is crucial to designing and calibrating car audio systems that sound amazing. If you want better sound from your car audio system, drop by a local specialty mobile enhancement retailer today. Ask to hear one of their demo vehicles and discuss the options for improving your vehicle’s stereo.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Product Spotlight: Momento M8 Max

Momento M8 Max

There are now hundreds of dash cameras on the market. If you are serious about protecting yourself from fraud and false accusations or simply want to capture those incredible once-in-a-lifetime moments, then you want a high-quality camera with excellent image quality. Momento’s latest flagship dash camera is called the M8 Max, and it’s the perfect choice for your car or truck. Let’s check it out!

Momento M8 Max Features

Let’s start by looking at the specifications of the new Momento M8 Max, which is also known as the MD-8400. This is the top-of-the-line in the three-model series. The M8 Max features a 4K Sony IMX image sensor for razor-sharp image capture at 30 frames per second. A secondary camera that can be pointed out the rear window features full HD (1920 x 1080 resolution) is also included in the kit. The system comes with a 64 GB memory card but can be upgraded to a 256 GB card for more storage. The M8 Max includes a GPS receiver to store vehicle location and speed.

The main power cable is also included in the box. This is a hard-wired cable, not a cigarette lighter plug. As such, your installer will need to find suitable constant 12-volt, switched accessory and ground connection points under the dash. A micro-SD to SD card adapter is also included.

Momento M8 Max
The camera on the Momento M8 Max can be adjusted to work with the slope of any windshield – from a Corvette to a transport truck.
Momento M8 Max
The M8 Max is ready for your installer to integrate into your vehicle to provide the ultimate protection against fraud and staged accidents.

Two- and Three-Camera Support Modes

Out of the box, the M8 Max is set up to handle dual-camera recording. However, if you want to add a third camera, like the IC6 interior camera, the M8 Max can be flashed with firmware to record from three sources simultaneously. The IC6 is ideal for taxis, limousines, buses, rideshare and company-owned vehicles. When flashed into three-camera mode, the system captures video from the front camera in 2K mode due to data storage bandwidth constraints.

Momento M8 Max
The M8 Max kit includes a full-HD resolution rear camera to capture what happens behind your vehicle.
Momento M8 Max
The IC6 Infrared interior camera is a perfect upgrade for taxi, Uber or Lyft operators to monitor occupant activity.

ECO Parking Mode

An essential feature of the M8 Max is its ECO parking mode. Unlike conventional cameras that use the image sensor to monitor the area in front of the vehicle, the M8 Max uses a low-power radar transceiver. If someone walks in front of your car or truck while the camera is in parking mode, the system will wake up and capture a video of the activity. Once the object has passed, it goes back into ECO Mode. The benefit of radar-based monitoring is that the camera consumes about 90% less power than video monitoring units. This means less drain on your vehicle battery and days of monitoring instead of hours.

Voice Recognition

The M8 Max includes voice recognition features. You can say “Hi, Momento,” then wait for the chime and say “Save Video.” The system will start a manual recording that is saved to a dedicated folder on the micro-SD card. Other voice commands include Enable and Disable Mic, Enable and Disable Wi-Fi, Switch Wi-Fi (between 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz modes), and Enable and Disable Privacy mode.

Compact, Flexible Design with Manual Controls

The Momento M8 Maxi-fi is one of the lowest-profile dash cameras on the market. It attaches to your windshield with the included 3M VHB tape behind the rearview mirror. Once in place, the camera tilts upwards or down to ensure perfect coverage in front of the vehicle. The viewing angle is 112 degrees on the horizontal plane and 96 degrees vertically.

There are two buttons on the face of the Momento M8 Max, making it very intuitive to use. Pressing the left Wi-Fi button toggles Wi-Fi on and off. Pressing the right REC (Record) button initiates a manual recording in the event you witness something. Holding the REC button for three seconds turns off the mic. Holding the Wi-Fi button for 10 seconds will format the memory card.

The Momento Smartphone App

All three Momento M8 dashcams are compatible with the free Momento App for Android and iOS devices. Once you have connected your smart device to the M8 Max using 2.4 or 5 GHz Wi-Fi, the app lets you view the live video feed from the camera. This is how your installer will initially set up the camera.

The app lets you view and download stored files from any of the five galleries: Driving, Driving Events, Parking, Parking Events and Manual. You can preview the video at 600p resolution or download the full-resolution version and save it with your files or images for sharing.

The app provides access to many configuration options. These options include sensitivity adjustments for the integrated accelerometer to determine when event videos will be recorded. You can also set the automatic low-battery cut-off voltage or allocate different storage space for driving and parking videos. You can also change vehicle speed units between MPH and KM/H, depending on whether or not the camera uses radar parking mode, camera exposure, and the optional Travelapse mode. In Travelapse, the camera records at one frame per second to compress a long trip into a short video. If the accelerometer detects an impact, the system will store a 30-frame-per-second video starting seven seconds before the event trigger. The app also allows you to initiate a firmware update if and when it is introduced.

Momento M8 Max
The Momento App provides access to stored videos and system configuration settings.

The Ultimate Driving Protection Solution

If you want a premium dash camera with excellent image quality and class-leading features, visit a local authorized retailer and ask for a demonstration of the Momento M8 Max. They can complete the installation to ensure your camera will work reliably to capture everything that happens while you’re driving.

For more information on Momento safety products, visit their website. You should also follow them on Facebook and Instagram. Finally, their YouTube channel has videos about all of their products.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Driver Safety, PRODUCTS, RESOURCE LIBRARY Tagged With: Momento

Explaining The Class SB Car Audio Amplifier

Class SB Amp

There will always be debates about whether a Class D amplifier can sound as good as a Class AB. We’ve proven that it all depends on who designs the amplifier. We also see mumblings about single-ended amps versus full-bridge designs. STMicroelectronics created a different and unexpected way to deliver efficient power. These amplifiers are categorized Class SB and Class SBI. Let’s see if we can explain how they work.

Amplifier Output Device Topologies

Before we dig into the Class SB amplifier, we need to clarify a few things. There are two ways to configure the driver devices (transistors or MOSFETS) to provide large amounts of current to speakers. In a Class A configuration, the output device is halfway on when no audio is playing. The audio signal can modulate the output from its resting point at 50% up to nearly 100% and down to nearly 0%. While extremely linear, these designs are notoriously inefficient and waste large amounts of energy. A Class A amplifier circuit has a maximum efficiency of 25% and only gets worse as the output level decreases from full. Playing nothing at all, a true Class A amplifier wastes half the maximum current delivery capability of the power supply as heat.

Class SB Amp
A generalization of how a transistor in a Class A amplifier operates.

In a Class B amplifier, we dedicate one transistor to the positive half of the audio waveform and a second to the negative half. When no music is playing, the output devices are functionally off.

Class SB Amp
A generalization of how transistors in a Class B amplifier operate.

We have to add a little voltage to the output devices so that the transition from one to the other is smooth. Many low-quality amplifiers don’t do this well. In those instances, we’ve seen a little step in the waveform through the transition. This step is called crossover distortion. When executed smoothly, there is no step. This mode of operation is commonly called a Class AB output device configuration. In reality, it’s just a voltage-biased Class B, but there’s clearly no going back on the name now.

Class SB Amp
A small amount of biasing in a Class AB amplifier eliminates crossover distortion and improves sound quality.

In this context, Class A and Class B are called output device topologies. These are the only two ways output devices can be wired.

Class D Operation

When we talk about Class D amplifiers, we aren’t discussing how the output devices are configured. Class D is a description of the signal used to drive the output devices. Most Class D amplifiers use a Class AB output device configuration.

As you can see in the image below, the analog audio waveform is chopped into little pieces by the Class D driver IC. The width of the spikes relative to the switching frequency represents the output level. Very narrow spikes produce small amounts of output, and very wide spikes produce high output levels.

Class SB Amp
Most Class D amplifiers use output devices in a Class AB configuration.

The benefit of Class D operation is that the output devices are switched fully on or off. They spend very little time part-way on. In essence, they block all current flow or allow it all through. Transistors and MOSFET devices are least efficient when they allow half the current through – as we saw in a Class A configuration. The result is a dramatic improvement in efficiency. Many well-engineered Class D amplifiers have 92% total efficiency.

Amplifier Integrated Circuits

Before we go off the rails with Class SB, let’s look at dedicated amplifier ICs. Almost every car radio for the last few decades uses a single chip as an amplifier. These chips typically have four channels of amplification and all the protection circuitry required to prevent DIYers from blowing up their radios. Most IC amplifiers provide 16 to 21 watts of power into 4-ohm loads from each channel.

Class SB Amp
Amplifier ICs like this example from Toshiba are commonplace in car radios.

Sony took things further with their High Power radios and used a Texas Instruments IC called the TAS5414C. In their head unit applications, I’ve measured over 42 watts of power from each channel. In what Sony calls their Subwoofer Direct mode, I’ve measured over 76 watts of power.

Class SB Amp
Sony’s High Power head units can easily produce 45 watts of continuous power from the four amplifier channels.

Bridge-Tied-Load Amplifiers

Most head units have only the vehicle’s battery voltage available to drive the speakers. They don’t typically have step-up power supplies like an amplifier. As such, we can only get about 13.5 or 14 volts across the speaker terminals. This means we are limited to a theoretical maximum of 24.5 watts. In reality, we see a few watts less as some voltage is wasted in the amplifier circuitry.

If your installer were to look at the output of a car radio at full power on an oscilloscope, you’d see the following waveforms on the speaker wires.

Class SB Amp
The waveforms present on the speaker wires of a typical car radio.

If we turn the volume down to almost nothing, we’d see the following:

Class SB Amp
The output of a typical car radio playing a sine wave at a very low volume.

As you can see, both speaker wires have a DC offset voltage. When no audio is playing, there’s about 6 to 6.5 volts present on the speaker wires. Because the voltage is common to both wires, the speaker doesn’t move. The speaker only responds to differences between the wires.

Now, let’s look at a single-ended amplifier. This would be an example of one channel of a typical car audio amplifier.

Class SB Amp
What your installer would measure with a scope probe on each terminal of a single-ended amplifier.

You can see that the probe with the green trace rests at the ground voltage. The probe with the purple trace shows the output voltage swinging from positive to negative and back. The speaker will move forward and rearward to follow the purple waveform.

STMicroelectronics’ Class SB and Class SBI

OK, now you should understand how output-switching devices can be configured and how different waveforms can be used to increase efficiency. STMicroelectronics combined things in the Class SB amplifiers to create something unique and, to put it mildly, creative. STMicroelectronics uses the SB abbreviation for “single-ended bridged” and SBI as “SB improved.” Their claim is Class AB sound quality with a 50% improvement in efficiency.

Class SB amplifiers function as single-ended amplifiers at low to moderate power levels. The waveform sweeps from negative to positive on one speaker lead while the other rests at ground.

Class SB Amp
The output of a Class SB amplifier operating at low to moderate levels.

If this were a typical Class AB amplifier, the output waveform would clip if we increased the signal to the amplifier such that the output tried to exceed the rail voltage limits. That would resemble the waveform below.

Class SB Amp
The waveform of a Class AB amplifier driven into clipping.

The Class SB amplifier gets creative when it runs out of rail voltage at high output levels. Check this out.

Class SB Amp
The oh-so-clever operation of the STM Class SB amplifier as seen on an oscilloscope.

When the main output reaches clipping, the “normally at ground” output increases voltage in the opposite direction. The result is a net increase in amplitude. That’s very creative. In application, having full control over every component in the amplifier is crucial to this design functioning properly. With everything housed in a single IC, STM has that control.

Class SB Amp
An example of a four-channel Flexiwatt-25 cased Class SB Power amplifier IC.

Is a Class SB Amplifier Better?

Before claiming that STMicroelectronics has reinvented the car audio amplifier, consider that these ICs have specific applications. They are designed to be compact and efficient. As such, amplifiers created with them at the core can be compact with smaller heatsinks than an equivalent Class AB amplifier. Further, these amplifiers are available with digital inputs. This connectivity makes them ideal for integrating into a closed-network infotainment system, like MOST, AVB or A2B offer. The amplifiers produce about 45 watts of power. This might be good for the main channels of a factory-installed car audio system but won’t be adequate for high-power aftermarket solutions or subwoofers.

What Do Consumers Need to Know about Class SB Amplifiers?

So, what does the typical consumer need to know about Class SB amplifiers? The answer is not much. That said, knowing what new technologies are in use is always good. Class SB amplifiers are primarily a solution for vehicle manufacturers and low- to mid-power audio systems. Installers and technicians must understand how to recognize audio signals from a Class SB amplifier when integrating digital signal processors and new amplifiers into a vehicle. Many, but not all, aftermarket audio upgrades work with Class SB-powered factory-installed source units. If you want more performance from your car audio system, drop by a local specialty mobile enhancement retailer and ask them about the amplifiers, speakers, source units and subwoofers that will deliver the sound you want.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Under-Seat Truck Subwoofers – Face Up or Down?

Truck Subwoofer

Over the last decade, the popularity of under-seat truck subwoofer upgrades has exploded. At least a dozen companies offer vehicle-specific solutions with shallow-mount subwoofers to add bass to these vehicles. If you’re perusing the enclosure options for your truck, you’ll notice two distinct options: enclosures with drivers that face upward into the seat bottom and those that face down into the floor. Is one design better than the other? Let’s discuss.

Truck Subwoofer Enclosures

Before we dive into the potential differences between up- and down-firing truck enclosures, let’s talk about the purpose of an enclosure. First and foremost, a subwoofer enclosure separates the sound coming from the back of the cone from the sound coming from the front. If you took a subwoofer out of its shipping carton and held it in your hand while playing music, you’d find it produces no bass. The lack of output is because the sounds coming from the front and back of the cone cancel each other out. When we put a subwoofer in an enclosure, it traps the sound coming from the back of the cone, and we only hear it from the front.

The second purpose of a subwoofer enclosure is to act as a high-pass filter to limit subwoofer cone excursion at very low frequencies. Without an enclosure, driver damage is possible with even moderate amounts of power. The air in the enclosure changes the compliance of the subwoofer suspension. More accurately, it makes it harder for the cone to move. Yes, this does seem counterproductive. Subwoofers need an enclosure to play 35 to 65 hertz loudly while remaining controlled at lower frequencies. Getting the enclosure design right is very important to the performance of the subwoofer system.

Truck Subwoofer
The T1S-1X10 from Rockford Fosgate will fit under or behind the seats of many pickup trucks to deliver great bass.

Down-Firing Subwoofer Enclosures

Down-firing subwoofer enclosure designs that aim the subwoofer into the floor are not new. There are many myths about down-firing subwoofers, though. Theories about low-frequency information reinforcement and “tightness” changes are prevalent. At extreme excursion levels, the proximity to the floor might result in a small amount of pressure pushing back on the cone. The closer to the floor the subwoofer is, the more this is a possibility. Yet it won’t significantly affect performance.

If you’ve read the BestCarAudio.com series of articles on Understanding Subwoofer Quality, you know that all subwoofers (and speakers) add moderate amounts of harmonic distortion to the signals they produce. These harmonics are typically second- and third-order, so twice and three times the fundamental frequencies. If a subwoofer plays a 50 hertz tone, the second harmonic is 100 hertz, and the third is 200 hertz. One benefit of firing a subwoofer down into the floor is that these higher frequencies might be somewhat attenuated. The attenuation amount depends on the floor’s proximity and the materials under the subwoofer (carpet, etc.).

Truck Subwoofer
KICKER offers 8-, 10-and 12-inch down-firing subwoofer enclosures that are perfect for pickup trucks.

Up-Firing Truck Subwoofer Enclosures

With an up-firing enclosure, we have a seat cushion to filter higher-frequency harmonic content. The difference between up- and down-firing subwoofer enclosures might not vary significantly in this context.

With a down-firing enclosure, the designer must provide adequate space between the subwoofer and floor to ensure that the cone and surround will never touch anything. There should also be sufficient space so that the sound produced by the subwoofer can escape into the vehicle. These criteria might result in the subwoofer being 1.5 to 2 inches off the floor. The drawback here is that this wastes some enclosure volume.

If the subwoofers are firing upward into a seat cushion, a grille over the subwoofer will allow the seat to sit directly on top of the driver. Bass frequencies can pass through the seat cushion with minimal obstruction.

Truck Subwoofer
This up-firing Chevy Silverado Phantom Fit enclosure from Audio Designs and Custom Graphics is available in several driver configurations.

If you’re shopping for a subwoofer enclosure for your truck, ask the product specialist you’re working with about the enclosure volumes. The number one issue with truck enclosures is volume. Most of them are too small, which results in boomy and sloppy bass reproduction. Choose the enclosure that has the most internal air volume.

But Wait, There’s More!

In researching this article, I read a few dozen discussions about down- and forward-firing home theater subwoofer enclosures. A common issue repeatedly demonstrated a misunderstanding in system design and calibration. There were many comments about how a subwoofer blended better with the main speakers firing backward into a wall versus out into the room. People had taken measurements with Room EQ Wizard to further the matter to corroborate their observations.

Of course there will be a difference! The subwoofer and the midbass speakers must be in phase at the crossover power for the transition to be smooth. Turning a home theater sub around without changing settings will reverse the effective acoustic polarity. Unless you’re unlucky and your sub is 90 degrees out of phase with the main speakers, one direction will work better than the other. Most home theater subwoofers have a polarity control switch on the amplifier panel. Better units will have a phase control knob.

What’s the takeaway from this second consideration? System calibration is crucial to getting the most from your car audio system. If you don’t have a digital signal processor (even though you should), then the technician installing the system should focus on speaker polarity and levels to produce the smoothest response possible. If you have a DSP, getting the phase between the subwoofers and the rest of the speakers right is crucial. This alignment can be fine-tuned with polarity and delay adjustments. When appropriately configured, and you have high-quality speakers and subwoofers that don’t add a lot of distortion, the bass will seem to come from the front of the vehicle. Midbass frequencies will be tight and dynamic with fantastic impact.

Truck Subwoofer
DSP-equipped amplifiers like the ARC Audio Blackbird are a great all-in-one solution to make any car audio system sound stunning.

Should I Choose an Up- or Down-Firing Truck Subwoofer Enclosure?

The final answer to choosing an up- or down-firing truck subwoofer enclosure is to select the solution that allows the subwoofers to sound their best. In most cases, this will mean going with an enclosure that offers the largest volume to reduce unwanted resonance. You may want to read the BestCarAudio.com article about enclosure stuffing to reduce resonance in sealed subwoofer enclosures. Having your installer pack the enclosure with Dacron or something similar might offer a significant improvement in sound quality.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

Why Do Speakers and Subwoofers Sometimes Have CCAW Voice Coils?

CCAW Voice Coil

You should be aware that copper-clad aluminum wire is the least-preferred option for connecting an amplifier to your vehicle’s battery or alternator. Copper-clad aluminum wire has more resistance for a given diameter than an all-copper cable. As a result, it wastes precious voltage and transforms it into heat when it could be allowing your amplifier to make more power. Why do many high-quality speakers and subwoofers use CCAW in their voice coils? Read on for an explanation.

Speaker Parameters and Frequency Response

No single specification can describe how a speaker or subwoofer will perform. To create a product that delivers flat response through its designed operating range, speaker design engineers need to balance several factors to achieve their design goals. These factors include the speaker’s size, resonant frequency, cone mass, suspension compliance, inductive properties and target power-handling capabilities.

CCAW Voice Coil
A comparison of a speaker with 5 grams added and subtracted from the cone assembly.

The graph above shows the predicted frequency response of a Rockford Fosgate T4652S woofer in red. The low-frequency response and efficiency are based primarily on the driver’s suspension compliance and the cone’s mass. The speaker’s voice coil inductance is what determines the high-frequency roll-off.

The yellow trace is the same driver, with 5 grams added to the moving mass value. As you can see, the driver is a few decibels louder at frequencies below 80 Hz and a few decibels less efficient above that frequency. The decrease in efficiency happens because the assembly is more challenging to accelerate. A second change is that the resonant frequency is lower.

The green trace is the same Rockford Fosgate driver simulation with 5 grams subtracted from the moving mass. As expected, the driver would produce less bass but be more efficient at higher frequencies.

Speaker engineers work hard to balance all these criteria to produce a product that will blend well with your subwoofers and offer good efficiency. If we take a given speaker design and add mass to the cone assembly, we increase how much bass it can produce but decrease its efficiency. Likewise, reducing the mass results in an increase in the speaker’s efficiency and a reduction in bass output.

Voice Coil Impedance Matters

Another factor that’s crucial to speaker design is voice coil impedance. When an engineer sets out to create a speaker, one of the target specifications will be for the driver to have a specific nominal impedance. Designing a speaker with a 2-ohm impedance doesn’t work if it’s intended for use with an amplifier designed for 4-ohm loads.

Speaker designers have different options for voice coil wire diameter to change the impedance of the winding. More wire means more impedance. Smaller diameter wire also increases the impedance.

However, they must create a voice coil winding tall enough to ensure that the driver remains linear at its excursion limits. The voice coil winding must also be tall enough to handle the heat it will dissipate. Dainty, small-diameter windings, like you’d find in entry-level speakers, don’t have enough physical size to dissipate large amounts of heat. When they get hot, the varnish on the wire melts, and the windings may short together or unravel. The result is a permanently damaged woofer. As such, larger-diameter windings, which use more wire, are necessary.

Another way to increase thermal power handling is to add additional layers to the voice coil. You may have seen four- and six-layer voice coils in some high-power subwoofers. These designs can handle more power than a two-layer coil. However, more copper means more resistance and more mass. The result of these mass increases is decreased speaker efficiency.

CCAW Voice Coil
An example of a speaker voice coil that has melted because of too much power. Image Credit: Elliot Sound Products

The Benefits of CCAW Voice Coils

Speaker design engineers often turn to CCAW to add resistance to a voice coil winding. For example, we might want a speaker to have a nominal impedance of 4 ohms. As such, the voice coil will require a specific amount of copper wire to hit that impedance. The designer could also use 1.62 times as much CCAW of the same diameter wire to reach the same impedance. We also want the voice coil assembly to hit a target mass to work with the cone, dust cap, spiders and surround to achieve a target mass. The choice of material for the voice coil former is also a variable.

CCAW has less mass per unit length than all-copper conductors. It also has more resistance per unit length.

Let’s look at the mass of a CCAW conductor that is 25% copper and 75% aluminum. First, we know copper has a specific gravity of 8.96. Aluminum has a specific gravity of 2.7. If we combine these in a ratio of three parts aluminum to one part copper, we have an alloy with a specific gravity of 4.265. That’s just under half the specific gravity of copper alone. For the sake of simplicity, you can generalize that CCAW weighs half as much as copper. The actual mass depends on the ratio of copper to aluminum, which varies significantly from each supplier.

Next, let’s look at resistance the same way. For a given area, copper has a resistance of 1.7×10-6 ohms per centimeter. Aluminum’s resistance is 2.7×10-6 ohms per centimeter. Most CCAW wiring offers 0.62 to 0.64 of the conductivity of pure copper.

So, a speaker designer can increase the length of the conductor in a voice coil using CCAW wire to hit a target size and impedance. They can switch to CCAW wire to decrease the mass of a voice coil assembly.

CCAW Voice Coil
A selection of four-layer subwoofer voice coils.

There’s No Correlation Between Amplifier Wiring and Voice Coil Design

So the next time you hear someone put down a speaker design because it features a CCAW voice coil, remind them that speaker design and power delivery goals are unrelated. When powering an amplifier, we want the lowest resistance wires possible. We want the lowest resistance wires possible when connecting a speaker or subwoofer to an amplifier. As such, we should use large-gauge, all-copper wiring. When it comes to speaker design, the goals are very different. The engineer wants a voice coil with a specific length, impedance and mass. A conductor with more resistance and less mass per unit length is one of the variables the designer can change to meet their goals.

This article is written and produced by the team at www.BestCarAudio.com. Reproduction or use of any kind is prohibited without the express written permission of 1sixty8 media.

Filed Under: ARTICLES, Car Audio, RESOURCE LIBRARY

  • « Previous Page
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • …
  • 91
  • Next Page »

Recent Articles

Compustar 2WG17 Remote Kit

Product Spotlight: Compustar 2WG17 Remote Kit

May 19, 2025 

Compustar was one of the first brands to allow consumers to choose a remote control package to accompany their remote start controller. Previously, we looked at flagship-level … [Read More...]

a black car in the snow with its headlight on and a hand holding a stopwatch off to the side

What’s the Ideal Car Warm-Up Time with a Remote Starter?

May 18, 2025 

Never in a million years did we think that the internet would debate the appropriate amount of time that’s ideal for a remote starter to warm up a car. Some folks believe that even … [Read More...]

color patterns

Fine-Tuning Your Sound: Understanding the Power of Parametric Equalizers

May 11, 2025 

When looking at the options for frequency response correction for audio systems, your installer has two choices: graphic or parametric equalizers. Both types of equalizers perform … [Read More...]

A car audio equalizer with blue highlights around it

Why Is a Car Audio Equalizer Important to Create Realistic Sound?

May 4, 2025 

The single most crucial upgrade a person can make to their car audio system is to incorporate a properly configured equalizer. Whether you have a radio and two speakers or a … [Read More...]

Customer Reviews

Subscribe to Our Website

Enter your email address to subscribe to our website and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Location


Get Directions to Audio Innovations

Audio Innovations

1105 Jim's Lane
Conway, AR 72032
Phone: 501-358-6545

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Services

  • Car Audio
  • Driver Safety Systems
  • Marine Audio
  • Motorcycle Audio
  • Radar and Laser Detector Systems
  • Remote Starters

Store Hours

SundayClosed
Monday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
SaturdayClosed

Copyright © 2025 Audio Innovations · Privacy Policy · Website by 1sixty8 media, inc. · Log in

 

Loading Comments...